A very interesting discussion on the pros and cons of the new Thunderbirds Are Go series, from my long-time collaborator Collette Knowles of Rough Magic Theatre.
Despite my initial suspicion, given the lack of puppets, the new reboot of Thunderbirds for ITV (Thunderbirds Are Go) has a lot of merit and is great fun to watch.
I tend to find in general that films and television that use CGI rather than puppetry are just not as effective. You can always tell when something is CGI rather than animated or using live puppetry and it does tend to feel a bit cheap, fake and disappointing. There are obviously exceptions. The work of Pixar for example does not attempt to make CGI look naturalistic but instead uses caricatured visuals which are much more effective.
Puppets have a character and expression all of their own and unlike CGI where every action is programmed a puppeteer can be surprised by the things their puppet does. A puppeteer does not impose a set of actions and movements upon the puppet, rather the…
View original post 1,375 more words